I've never enjoyed longform campaign actual plays much either. It's just not feasible to keep up with, and unless you're playing, most campaign RPGs have too much bookkeeping to pay attention to. And even as a background listen, which I'm sure is how most people do it, gets dull.
And yet I've watched quite a few though. It works only if I enjoy the people playing, their wits etc. I have no chemistry with Critical Roll, Mercer included. But really enjoyed Acquisition Incorporated: C Team.
But these days the only kind of APs I find myself watching and consistently enjoying is faster indie RPG one-shots. In particular, Mystery Quest (YouTube) where Tom runs a one-shot for a rotating cast of friends (all of whom very funny people) each month. No miniatures, barely any rules referencing. The heaviest game they run is CoC, and it never gets in the way! There's even a "duet" Thousand Year Old Vampire session that went surprisingly well.
Anytime any other podcast or channel I already follow for their humor and chemistry does a one shot I also like to listen. The short ones are always a delight. No fatigue, no fomo. It works.
I don't think I'd ever even consider watching a campaign AP had I started here. There are just not fun unless you're in them, playing.